Introduction: Why We Cheer for the Underdog
There’s something timeless and universally magnetic about the underdog story. From Rocky Balboa to Rudy Ruettiger, audiences have long gravitated toward tales where the odds are stacked high and the fight seems insurmountable. One modern film that stands out in this lineage is Gabriele Muccino’s The Pursuit of Happyness (2006), starring Will Smith. This real-life tale of Chris Gardner’s struggle from homelessness to becoming a successful stockbroker is not just inspirational—it’s a masterclass in emotionally resonant screenwriting.
In this article, we’re diving deep into the storytelling elements that make The Pursuit of Happyness a compelling example of underdog cinema. We’ll explore its emotional core, character arc, structure, and writing choices that screenwriters can learn from when crafting stories that tug at the heart.
1. Grounding Emotion in Reality: The True Story Behind the Film
Before a single line of dialogue is written, the foundation of any story matters. The Pursuit of Happyness is rooted in the real-life story of Chris Gardner, who, in the early 1980s, struggled with homelessness while raising his young son and pursuing a prestigious internship at a stock brokerage firm.
This real-world backdrop isn’t just context—it’s part of the emotional architecture of the film. The stakes aren’t theoretical. The poverty is real. The child depending on Gardner is real. The very title, a deliberate misspelling found on a daycare sign in the film, reflects the real and flawed environment in which hope must bloom.
For screenwriters, this underscores a key lesson: emotional resonance often comes from specificity. By rooting the story in grounded, tangible detail—such as Gardner selling bone density scanners or sleeping in a subway bathroom—the audience is drawn closer to the character’s world.
2. The Underdog Formula: Structure and Stakes
Let’s break down the classic underdog narrative structure:
- Act I: Introduce the character’s normal world and inciting struggle.
- Act II: Escalating challenges and near-breaking points.
- Act III: The breakthrough moment, often earned through persistence, self-sacrifice, and growth.
The Pursuit of Happyness hits these beats with precision.
In Act I, we meet Chris as a struggling salesman whose financial woes are fracturing his marriage. The inciting incident comes early: he decides to pursue a highly competitive unpaid internship at Dean Witter.
Act II is where the film truly earns its emotional weight. Chris is evicted, forced to sleep in shelters, and must juggle full-time unpaid work with full-time single parenting. Each setback doesn’t just make the audience sympathize—they empathize, often asking themselves, What would I do in his place?
The film culminates in Act III with a hard-won victory. There is no grand speech. No rousing montage. Just a quiet moment when Chris is offered the job. The silence is deafening. His tears say what words cannot.
For writers, this reminds us: it’s not about manufacturing drama. It’s about earning it.
3. The Power of the Personal: Fatherhood as Emotional Core
At the heart of The Pursuit of Happyness is not finance or social mobility. It’s fatherhood.
Chris Gardner’s relationship with his son (played by Will Smith’s real-life son, Jaden Smith) gives the story its heartbeat. Unlike many stories where children are passive burdens or background noise, here the child is central. Chris isn’t just fighting for his dream—he’s fighting for his son’s sense of stability and security.
The emotional scenes between father and son—whether sharing jokes, sleeping in a subway bathroom, or racing to a homeless shelter—are never manipulative. They feel lived-in. Raw. Honest.
For screenwriters, this is a critical takeaway: relationships give stakes their true meaning. It’s not just what a character wants—it’s why they want it. And in Chris’s case, it’s so his son doesn’t lose faith in him—or in life.
4. Show, Don’t Tell: Writing Without Preaching
The screenplay by Steven Conrad is a masterclass in restraint. There are no long-winded speeches about dreams or justice. Instead, the story unfolds in action and image.
Take the now-iconic scene of Chris and his son playing basketball. Chris discourages his son from dreaming too big, only to catch himself moments later and say:
“Don’t ever let somebody tell you… you can’t do something. Not even me.”
It’s brief. Simple. Earned. And unforgettable.
The scene works because it’s unexpected. Chris isn’t a perfect hero. He’s exhausted, frustrated, and human. And when he corrects himself, it feels like real growth—something screenwriters should aim for in every character arc.
5. The Economic Reality of Dreams: Subtext as Social Commentary
While not overtly political, the film subtly critiques systemic issues: housing insecurity, unpaid labor, the precariousness of the American Dream. Yet it does so without soapboxing.
Instead, these themes are woven into the fabric of Chris’s daily life. Sleeping in a bathroom stall. Running to make daycare pickup. Standing in line at a homeless shelter in a suit.
The film makes a quiet but powerful statement: in America, chasing a dream can cost everything—even your dignity. That’s what makes the eventual payoff so moving.
For writers, this shows how theme and subtext can be embedded into plot and setting. If you want to say something about the world, show it through how your character lives.
6. Performance and Writing: When Words Meet Acting
Will Smith’s performance elevates the writing, but it’s the writing that gives him room to shine. The dialogue is sparse, deliberate, and often silent where lesser scripts might explain too much.
One of the most powerful moments comes without dialogue: when Chris is finally offered the job. He thanks the executives, walks out, and—outside their earshot—lets out a guttural sob of joy.
That moment wasn’t about clever writing. It was about trusting the character’s journey. As screenwriters, we should remember that sometimes the most powerful line is no line at all.
7. Hope Is a Muscle: Why This Story Endures
Audiences return to The Pursuit of Happyness not because it’s a fairy tale, but because it reflects a hard truth: hope isn’t handed out—it’s earned. Chris Gardner doesn’t succeed despite the struggle; he succeeds through it.
There’s no deus ex machina. No lucky break. Just persistence, resourcefulness, and grit.
In screenwriting terms, this is where the emotional payoff truly lands. You can throw your character into the pit—but they have to claw their own way out. When they do, the audience feels it with them.
Final Thoughts: Writing for the Ones Who Keep Going
Underdog stories aren’t just about beating the odds—they’re about surviving long enough to get a chance. The Pursuit of Happyness reminds us that stories rooted in personal stakes, emotional truth, and quiet resilience can hit harder than the loudest blockbusters.
As screenwriters, we can learn a lot from this film:
- Root your characters in reality.
- Let relationships drive emotion.
- Trust the audience to feel without being told.
- Let hope cost something.
In the end, when you write for the underdog, you write for the audience’s better angels—the part of them still willing to believe that effort matters, that love sustains, and that happiness, no matter how elusive, is worth the pursuit.
✍️ Whether you’re mastering the art of dialogue, structure, or character development, the power of AI can be a game-changer in your writing journey. My Free Ebook, ‘AI for Authors’ delves into how AI-powered prompts can provide a unique edge to your storytelling process. If you’re intrigued by the prospect of supercharging your fiction skills, download your free copy today and explore new horizons in creative writing.
A.I. in Screen Trade 