In Peter Weir’s 1993 film “Fearless,” Jeff Bridges plays Max Klein, a man who survives a catastrophic plane crash only to find himself fundamentally altered by the experience. The film serves as a masterclass in portraying trauma and recovery on screen, offering valuable lessons for writers tackling these challenging themes in their own work.
The Weight of the Moment
When writing about trauma, many screenwriters make the mistake of focusing solely on the traumatic event itself. While the inciting incident is crucial, it’s the aftermath—the ripples that spread through a character’s life—that often proves most compelling. In “Fearless,” the plane crash occurs in the first act, but the story’s heart lies in Max’s transformed relationship with mortality, his family, and his own identity.
The key is understanding that trauma isn’t just about what happened; it’s about how that event reshapes a character’s entire worldview. Max’s newfound fearlessness isn’t portrayed as superheroic but as a complex psychological response that both empowers and isolates him. This nuanced approach offers audiences a more authentic exploration of post-traumatic growth and dysfunction.
Building the Before and After
One of the most effective techniques in portraying trauma is establishing a clear “before” and “after” for your character. However, this doesn’t mean simply showing two different versions of the same person. Instead, focus on the subtle ways trauma manifests in everyday moments:
- Changed relationships with loved ones
- Altered daily routines and habits
- New triggers and associations
- Shifted perspectives on previously important matters
- Modified coping mechanisms
In your screenplay, these changes should be revealed gradually rather than announced explicitly. Show your character struggling with seemingly simple tasks that were once automatic, or finding comfort in unexpected places. Let the audience piece together the transformation through carefully crafted scenes and moments.
The Language of Trauma
When writing dialogue for traumatized characters, resist the urge to make them overtly articulate about their experiences. Trauma often defies easy verbalization. Instead, look for ways to communicate through:
- Subtext in ordinary conversations
- Physical behaviors and reactions
- Environmental interactions
- Metaphoric or symbolic expressions
- Silence and what remains unsaid
Consider how “Fearless” uses Max’s relationship with food as a metaphor for his altered state. His ability to eat strawberries (to which he was previously allergic) becomes a powerful symbol of his disconnection from his former self.
Recovery Isn’t Linear
One of the most common pitfalls in writing about recovery is portraying it as a straightforward journey from broken to healed. Real recovery rarely follows such a neat arc. Your story will feel more authentic if you:
- Include setbacks and false starts
- Show progress in one area while regression occurs in another
- Acknowledge that some changes are permanent
- Recognize that “healing” doesn’t mean returning to who one was before
The goal isn’t to return your character to their previous state but to show them integrating their experience into a new way of being. This might mean that some relationships can’t be salvaged, some beliefs remain permanently altered, or some wounds never fully close.
Supporting Characters: The Web of Impact
Trauma doesn’t exist in isolation. When writing about a character’s traumatic experience, consider how it affects their entire social ecosystem. Supporting characters serve several crucial functions:
- Mirrors reflecting the protagonist’s changes
- Anchors to pre-trauma identity
- Catalysts for both healing and regression
- Representations of different coping mechanisms
- Vessels for audience empathy
In “Fearless,” Rosie Perez’s character Carla provides a different perspective on survival guilt and grief, while Isabella Rossellini’s therapist character offers a framework for understanding trauma without reducing it to clinical terms.
Technical Considerations
When crafting scenes dealing with trauma and recovery, pay special attention to:
Pacing
- Vary the rhythm between intense moments and quieter scenes
- Use silence and stillness effectively
- Allow space for emotional impact to land
Point of View
- Consider when to stay close to your protagonist’s perspective
- Know when to pull back for context
- Use subjective experience to convey psychological states
Sensory Details
- Include specific sensory triggers
- Show how everyday stimuli can become charged with new meaning
- Use sound and visual motifs to connect past and present
The Ethics of Representation
As screenwriters, we have a responsibility to portray trauma and recovery thoughtfully. This means:
- Researching thoroughly and consulting experts when possible
- Avoiding exploitation or sensationalism
- Considering the impact on viewers who have experienced similar trauma
- Being mindful of cultural and social contexts
- Balancing authenticity with audience engagement
Finding Hope Without Easy Answers
Perhaps the most challenging aspect of writing about trauma is striking the right balance between hope and realism. Your ending doesn’t need to show complete recovery, but it should offer something meaningful—whether that’s acceptance, understanding, or a new way forward.
In “Fearless,” Max’s journey concludes not with a return to his old self but with a reconciliation between his transformed identity and his need to remain connected to life and love. This kind of complex resolution respects both the gravity of trauma and the human capacity for adaptation and growth.
Conclusion
Writing about trauma and recovery requires a delicate balance of research, empathy, and craftsmanship. By focusing on the subtle complexities of psychological transformation, the non-linear nature of healing, and the ripple effects through relationships, writers can create stories that resonate deeply while avoiding common pitfalls and clichés.
Remember that your goal isn’t to provide neat solutions but to explore the messy, challenging, and ultimately human process of grappling with life-altering experiences. When done well, these stories can offer both recognition for those who have experienced trauma and insight for those seeking to understand it better.
✍️ Whether you’re mastering the art of dialogue, structure, or character development, the power of AI can be a game-changer in your writing journey. My Free Ebook, ‘AI for Authors’ delves into how AI-powered prompts can provide a unique edge to your storytelling process. If you’re intrigued by the prospect of supercharging your fiction skills, download your free copy today and explore new horizons in creative writing.
A.I. in Screen Trade 