Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly becoming a pivotal force in many industries, and Hollywood is no exception. From animation to voice acting and even scriptwriting, AI is transforming the creative landscape. This article examines AI’s integration into screenwriting and the broader entertainment industry, focusing on recent developments in the animation sector, the SAG-AFTRA strike, and Hollywood’s evolving stance on AI. By understanding these shifts, writers, producers, and other creative professionals can better navigate the changing environment.
The Evolution of AI in Animation and Screenwriting
The animation industry has long been at the forefront of integrating new technologies. Over the past decade, CGI, motion capture, and now AI have dramatically altered how animation is produced. One of the most significant developments occurred when Kartoon Studios unveiled two AI-driven educational series created largely through artificial intelligence, utilizing tools like ChatGPT for scriptwriting and AI-driven animation for production. These series, despite the technological advancements, failed to gain much traction, with underwhelming viewership numbers, signaling that AI still has considerable hurdles to overcome in winning over audiences.
Yet, AI’s role in the animation industry is expanding, not just in animation, but in storytelling as well. Studios like Toonstar are leveraging AI to streamline production, claiming that AI has made processes up to 80% faster. This efficiency boost represents an opportunity for smaller production houses that might not have the financial backing of larger studios like Pixar or DreamWorks. Still, the push toward AI has been met with substantial resistance from industry professionals.
The Threat of AI: Job Displacement and Outsourcing
The primary concern regarding AI’s proliferation is job displacement. Predictions suggest that AI could eliminate up to 90% of animation artist positions, a frightening prospect for many in the field. For screenwriters, voice actors, and animators alike, AI threatens to replace roles that rely on creativity and emotional depth—an area where AI still struggles.
The Animation Guild, under the leadership of Jeanette Moreno King, is vocal about these concerns. Representing over 5,000 animation professionals, the union is currently embroiled in contract negotiations with major studios like Netflix and Pixar. AI, along with the outsourcing of animation to non-union foreign studios, such as Disney’s Vancouver studio, poses a direct challenge to job security.
The outsourcing issue is not new to the union. Historically, The Animation Guild secured protections against outsourcing in 1979, only to lose them by 1982. Today, without any significant protections in place, animators and artists are fighting an uphill battle. With the rise of AI, the guild is pushing for more robust contractual protections that prevent studios from replacing skilled labor with algorithms.
AI’s Impact on Hollywood Unions
The growing influence of AI has reached beyond animation. In the world of video game performance, SAG-AFTRA, a labor union representing actors, is also grappling with AI. Video game companies like Activision Blizzard and Electronic Arts have proposed partial protections for performers against AI, but these were dismissed by the union as “dangerously incomplete,” particularly for motion capture and stunt performers. The concern? AI could one day replicate human performances without proper compensation or consent. Jasiri Booker and Seth Allyn Austin, both union performers, have expressed anxiety over the future of their craft if AI continues to evolve unchecked.
SAG-AFTRA‘s fight mirrors concerns raised by animation professionals. While studios argue that AI could simply be a tool for enhancement, many performers fear a more dystopian outcome where AI-rendered characters replace live actors altogether. During the ongoing strike against major video game companies, solidarity from other industry unions, including the Writers Guild of America (WGA), demonstrates the widespread anxiety that AI poses across different creative fields.
AI in Screenwriting: An Opportunity or a Challenge?
The introduction of AI in screenwriting represents a double-edged sword. On one hand, AI tools like ChatGPT can assist with brainstorming, dialogue generation, and even structural analysis of scripts. For example, Kartoon Studios‘ use of ChatGPT to write educational scripts was lauded as a way to cut production costs and speed up content delivery. However, the resulting product received little fanfare, suggesting that AI’s creative outputs still lack the nuance and emotional depth that human writers bring to the table.
For screenwriters, the use of AI raises existential questions: Will AI replace human creativity, or will it serve as an assistive tool? The nuanced writing seen in films like Ex Machina or Breaking Bad illustrates that great storytelling often comes from deeply human experiences. Ex Machina, for instance, isn’t just a story about AI; it is a philosophical exploration of what it means to be human. These layers of complexity, driven by character development and emotional arcs, are difficult to replicate with algorithms.
While AI might be able to assist in the more mechanical aspects of writing—plot structure, character names, or dialogue—it’s unlikely to ever fully replace the human touch needed to craft emotionally resonant narratives. As seen in Breaking Bad, writing is not just about advancing the plot but about creating layered, morally complex characters. AI, in its current form, lacks the ability to tap into the full range of human emotions, which remains crucial in film and television.
Industry Response to AI: Hesitation and Legal Challenges
Hollywood’s reaction to AI in storytelling and production has been mixed. Major figures like Ted Sarandos, co-CEO of Netflix, and Richard Hickey from Moonbug Entertainment, have both expressed caution. Their hesitancy stems from the belief that storytelling should prioritize quality, not just efficiency. Sarandos, for example, underscored the importance of “authenticity” in storytelling, a concept that AI might struggle to fully grasp.
On the legal front, AI-generated content faces significant challenges, especially when it comes to intellectual property. In the U.S., the Copyright Office currently does not grant copyrights to machine-generated works. This legal gray area has made many studios wary of fully embracing AI-driven content. Without clear guidelines on who owns AI-generated works, studios risk potential lawsuits or other legal disputes.
For example, The New York Times and other major publications have already taken legal action against OpenAI for allegedly using their content to train its language models without proper permission. Such disputes raise broader questions about the ethical and legal implications of using AI in the creative process, a conversation that Hollywood cannot afford to ignore as AI becomes more entrenched in the industry.
The Future of AI in Hollywood: Balancing Innovation with Ethics
As AI technology continues to evolve, Hollywood faces a crucial crossroads. While AI can streamline certain production tasks, reduce costs, and open up new creative possibilities, its rapid advancement also presents ethical challenges. The threat of job displacement looms large, and the outsourcing of labor to non-union foreign studios only exacerbates the problem. AI, if left unchecked, could lead to a world where creativity becomes secondary to efficiency.
However, there is a way forward. Unions like The Animation Guild and SAG-AFTRA are advocating for stronger protections against the unchecked use of AI. These negotiations could set important precedents for other sectors in Hollywood, ensuring that AI is used as a tool to assist creators, not replace them. As seen with the Kartoon Studios experiment, the success of AI in storytelling will depend largely on how well it is integrated with human creativity and emotional insight.
In the end, AI’s role in screenwriting and Hollywood will likely be one of augmentation rather than replacement. The best stories are those that reflect the complexity of the human experience—something that AI, for all its technical prowess, has yet to master. The future of storytelling will belong to those who can successfully blend technological innovation with the timeless elements of narrative craft.
✍️ Whether you’re mastering the art of dialogue, structure, or character development, the power of AI can be a game-changer in your writing journey. My Free Ebook, ‘AI for Authors’ delves into how AI-powered prompts can provide a unique edge to your storytelling process. If you’re intrigued by the prospect of supercharging your fiction skills, download your free copy today and explore new horizons in creative writing.
A.I. in Screen Trade 