Introduction & The Legacy of ‘Game of Thrones’
Just uttering the words “Game of Thrones” evokes a flurry of emotions that span the spectrum from awe to outrage. Adapted from George R.R. Martin’s unfinished but legendary book series “A Song of Ice and Fire,” this high fantasy epic didn’t just conquer our TV screens; it became a global cultural touchstone. It’s hard to come by a series that so skillfully utilized screenplay structure and writing quality to build a mythical realm complete with deeply flawed, relatable characters and intricate, jaw-dropping plotlines.
From the breathtaking landscapes of Westeros and Essos to the vivid ensemble of characters, “Game of Thrones” initially showed us the art of adapting complex literary material into a visual medium. You’d think that writing a screenplay of such a grand scope would be a writer’s nightmare, but the early seasons managed to pull it off beautifully. Let’s take the first season, for instance, it followed a classic screenplay structure often resembling the Three-Act model. The first act laid out the status quo, the second act developed the conflicts, and the third act offered some semblance of resolution that led to more questions. This meticulous scaffolding gave way to incredible story arcs like Ned Stark’s grim lesson on honor or Tyrion Lannister’s complex relationship with his family. It was as if the writers were adhering to some of the most timeless writing tips, creating relatable characters, building suspense, and utilizing foreshadowing like seasoned pros.
Remember the “Red Wedding?” The sheer dread that led up to it was palpable. How could it not be? With characters we had invested in, and stakes that were undeniably high, we were led to believe in the possibility of a brighter future. It was as if the screenplay’s structure mirrored our own hopes and fears. The writers took the writing prompts provided by the novels and expanded them, creating moments that would forever be etched in the annals of television history.
But somewhere along the journey, the tides shifted dramatically. The narrative, once layered with complexity and depth, began to take shortcuts. Even the most casual viewer could spot glaring inconsistencies in the plot and the characters’ motivations. Where once Daenerys Targaryen was a nuanced anti-heroine grappling with the specter of her family’s madness, she turned into a caricature almost overnight. Jaime Lannister’s redemption arc? It culminated in an about-face that left audiences worldwide scratching their heads. The last season felt especially rushed, as though the writers were trying to land a crashing plane, but it’s important to note that the rot had set in earlier.
Perhaps the disparity between the early and final seasons can be attributed to the show outpacing Martin’s books, but that’s too simplistic an explanation. An array of factors contributed to this shift, ranging from the expectations generated by fan theories to an evident fatigue in storytelling. The latter seasons failed to apply many of the principles of screenplay structure that had worked so well earlier. The story arc of Jon Snow, for example, was a mixed bag that seemed to abide by no known laws of narrative gravity. A secret Targaryen, a resurrected hero, a man torn between love and duty—these facets culminated in a series of actions in the final episodes that felt disjointed and unearned.
For a series that once served as a masterclass in screenwriting, the decline in the quality of its storytelling was nothing short of a tragedy. The characters, once treated with so much care and complexity, became pawns in a poorly executed endgame. What was once a promising tale turned into a cautionary anecdote for storytellers everywhere. It’s like a textbook example of how not to neglect screenplay structure and writing quality when navigating the stormy waters of high-stakes drama.
From Intricacy to Incoherence: Where the Final Seasons Went Wrong
No one expects a high-fantasy series of such magnitude to maintain perfect coherence. The very nature of sprawling epics like “Game of Thrones” allows for some inconsistencies or narrative hiccups. However, what fans didn’t bargain for was the jarring decline in narrative integrity that transpired over the final seasons. Let’s dissect some key areas where the show faltered, unraveling the very tapestry of storytelling excellence it once wove.
Rushed Arcs: A Descent into Chaos
When you’re dealing with long-form storytelling, one of the most crucial screenwriting tips is pacing. Pacing isn’t just about plot; it’s about giving your characters and the world they inhabit enough breathing space to evolve naturally. The final seasons felt like a mad dash to the finish line. Take, for example, Daenerys’ journey from liberator to tyrant. The seeds for her transformation were sown in the narrative soil, but they sprouted into a full-fledged Mad Queen almost overnight. Her character arc, once a meticulous construction, was now a casualty of impulsive writing choices.
Character Inconsistencies: Betraying Established Norms
Jaime Lannister’s storyline is a perfect case study in the power of consistent character development—until it isn’t. His redemptive arc was built season after season, making us invest emotionally in his transformation. Then came the undoing. Despite years of moral grappling, Jaime reverted back to his old self, throwing away his redemption like it was yesterday’s news. This wasn’t just inconsistent; it felt like a betrayal of one of the most fundamental writing tips – always stay true to your characters.
Screenplay Structure: Crumbling Foundations
The latter seasons often disregarded the basic principles of screenplay structure, which led to a crumbling narrative. In storytelling, it’s often said that the stakes should gradually increase to maintain tension. Unfortunately, the show failed to do that effectively in its final act. The climactic “Battle of Winterfell” against the Night King was positioned before the final confrontation in King’s Landing. This was problematic for many reasons, not least of which was the jarring tonal shift from an apocalyptic showdown to a political coup.
The Lost Art of Foreshadowing and Payoff
Remember Chekhov’s Gun? “If you say in the first chapter that there is a rifle hanging on the wall, in the second or third chapter, it absolutely must go off.” Well, it seems the writers forgot this critical element of writing a screenplay. The narrative was rife with unfulfilled promises and half-baked payoffs. Bran’s powers as the Three-Eyed Raven had tremendous potential but were underutilized. What could have been a stunning reveal of Jon Snow’s lineage ended up having minimal impact on the story’s conclusion.
Where it All Collapsed: The Finale
The series finale was perhaps the apex of these missteps. Rushed resolutions, uncharacteristic choices, and a sudden, almost off-hand coronation of a new king—it was as though the writers were ticking boxes rather than crafting a resonant narrative. The screenplay’s structure didn’t build up to these moments in a way that felt earned or satisfying. Rather than employing the screenwriting tips that make for a compelling climax and resolution, the finale seemed to abandon them altogether.
The closing of the “Game of Thrones” series offers a lesson in the fragility of storytelling. Good characters and an enticing plot are nothing without structural integrity. When the screenplay structure is compromised, everything that was once good can crumble like a house of cards. As you embark on the journey of writing a screenplay or any narrative form, remember that the devil is in the details. Attention to pacing, consistency, and structural cohesiveness is not optional; it’s essential. In the end, the downfall of “Game of Thrones” serves as a stark reminder—pun intended—of the perils of neglecting these narrative cornerstones.
Lessons Learned: Screenwriting Takeaways from the Fall of a Giant
The tale of “Game of Thrones” is like a cautionary fable for writers—filled with lessons on what to avoid if you aim to build a strong, enduring narrative. Let’s not just lament the fall; let’s glean some invaluable takeaways for our own creative endeavors.
Respecting the Process: Slow Cooking Over Fast Food
First and foremost, good storytelling is not a sprint; it’s a marathon. One of the pivotal writing tips I can give is this: let your characters and plots mature organically. You wouldn’t cook a stew by throwing all the ingredients in a pot and cranking the heat to max. The same goes for writing. Slow cooking ensures that each element—be it character traits, pivotal events, or plot twists—has time to integrate seamlessly into the narrative. So, if you’re writing a screenplay, don’t rush the arcs. Give your characters room to grow, to stumble, and to evolve.
Crafting 3D Characters: Writing Prompts for Richer Personalities
One tool that could prove handy here is the use of writing prompts for character development. Pose hypothetical scenarios for your characters, both mundane and extreme. How would they react if they found a wallet on the street? What if they were falsely accused of a crime? This exercise isn’t just fun; it’s a way to uncover hidden facets of your characters that you can later weave into your narrative. Remember, multi-dimensional characters are far more engrossing and believable than cardboard cutouts.
Staying True to Your Structure: A Blueprint for Success
Don’t underestimate the importance of a well-thought-out screenplay structure. Before diving into the story, lay down a blueprint. Just as architects wouldn’t build a house without a comprehensive plan, you shouldn’t embark on a screenplay without a clear understanding of its structural needs. Does the narrative require a three-act or a five-act structure? What are the pivot points? When and how should the climax occur? These questions can serve as your North Star, guiding you through the intricate maze of long-form storytelling.
Narrative Promises: The Sacred Vows of Storytelling
If you introduce a gun in Act One, it must go off by Act Three. This is not just about foreshadowing; it’s about maintaining narrative integrity and fulfilling the promises you’ve made to your audience. Any element you introduce should have a purpose, even if that purpose is to mislead the audience for a plot twist. But for heaven’s sake, make sure it has some effect. Narrative promises left unfulfilled can lead to audience frustration and, worse, disengagement.
Walking the Tightrope: Balancing Complexity and Coherence
A high-fantasy epic like “Game of Thrones” is inherently complex, but complexity shouldn’t come at the cost of coherence. One of the essential writing tips for maintaining coherence in a complex narrative is to keep an eye on the through-line. What’s the core idea? What themes recur throughout the story? Whenever you introduce a new subplot or character, ask yourself how it serves the overarching narrative.
The Takeaway: Narrative Integrity is King
In the realm of storytelling, narrative integrity reigns supreme. It’s the glue that holds the various elements together in a cohesive, engaging fashion. From pacing to character development, from structure to thematic consistency, every aspect needs to be calibrated with precision. If there’s one thing to take away from the rise and fall of “Game of Thrones,” it’s that even the most captivating of stories can unravel if these elements are mishandled.
As you embark on your own journey of writing a screenplay, or any other form of narrative, let this be your guide. Be meticulous, be patient, but above all, be true to the world you’ve created and the characters who inhabit it. In the game of thrones, as in the game of storytelling, you win or you die. There is no middle ground.
✍️ Whether you’re mastering the art of dialogue, structure, or character development, the power of AI can be a game-changer in your writing journey. My Free Ebook, ‘AI for Authors’ delves into how AI-powered prompts can provide a unique edge to your storytelling process. If you’re intrigued by the prospect of supercharging your fiction skills, download your free copy today and explore new horizons in creative writing.
A.I. in Screen Trade 