Introduction: The Unconventional Realism of ‘Blue Valentine’
Ah, romance! The genre that gave us such classics as “Gone with the Wind,” and modern tear-jerkers like “The Notebook.” Romance has a legacy in film that has traditionally been synonymous with grand gestures, steamy chemistry, and happily-ever-afters. Then comes a film like Blue Valentine, directed by Derek Cianfrance, that promptly flips the table. It’s the kind of romantic drama that makes you question the genre’s longstanding tropes.
But what sets ‘Blue Valentine’ apart? Why does it linger in your mind long after the credits roll, haunting you with its raw portrayal of love and loss? Well, my fellow scribes, it’s not just the performances by Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams (though, c’mon, they were sensational), it’s the audacious realism infused into the very fabric of its screenplay. This film takes a sledgehammer to the fairy tale castle of romantic ideals, shaking the foundation to let us peek at the complexities beneath.
To understand the unconventional realism of ‘Blue Valentine,’ you first need to grasp its screenplay structure, which itself is a fascinating specimen. The typical romance screenplay goes a little something like this: two people meet (the setup), they fall in love (the confrontation), and then they either end up together or don’t, depending on whether you’re watching a comedy or a tragedy. However, ‘Blue Valentine’ mixes this all up, employing a non-linear structure that intercuts scenes from the beginning and the end of a relationship, refusing to let you settle into the comforting arms of predictability. The film is a refreshing divergence from the formulaic three-act structure we often see. It’s as if Derek Cianfrance took a look at Syd Field’s “Screenplay” and decided, “Nice tips, but I’m going my own way.”
Why does this matter? For anyone keen on writing a screenplay that dares to be different, ‘Blue Valentine’ is a masterclass in how to keep audiences anchored while shifting timelines. This also enables the screenplay to delve deeper into its characters, showing not just the idyllic “how we met” scenes, but the grueling, heartbreaking “why it all fell apart” moments. The timeline shifts keep you guessing, and in doing so, they more authentically represent the jagged course of real-life relationships. No rose-tinted glasses here; just the unfiltered highs and lows of love.
From a writing tips perspective, it’s invaluable to see how a film can challenge narrative norms and still grip audiences emotionally. A balanced blend of storytelling techniques can offer both freshness and familiarity. For ‘Blue Valentine,’ that balance is struck through its screenplay, but the principles are equally relevant whether you’re penning a short story, novel, or a script of your own. Don’t be afraid to take a scalpel to those pre-established structures, folks. No one remembers the writers who played it safe; they remember the ones who made them feel something, who made them think.
Realism in storytelling doesn’t just demand the eschewing of conventional narrative arcs; it calls for the courage to portray life as it is, not as we wish it to be. If you’re a fan of the romantic genre, the initial watch of ‘Blue Valentine’ might feel like a slap in the face. It defies the conditioned expectation of cinematic love, revealing instead the struggles that are often glossed over in favor of picture-perfect moments.
While most romantic movies are content serving us the appetizer and dessert, ‘Blue Valentine’ insists we chew on the meat and bones of a relationship, sinewy and tough as they might be. And in doing so, it carves a space for itself as a touchstone for realistic romance, defying traditional screenwriting paradigms, and inviting writers to do the same.
So, the next time you find yourself staring at a blank screen, cursor blinking away as you contemplate how to breathe life into your characters or structure your next great screenplay, maybe give ‘Blue Valentine’ another watch. Not for its melancholy or its realism, but for its audacity to be both authentic and impactful. After all, isn’t that what we, as writers, strive for—to tell stories that resonate on multiple levels, stories that are as complex and unpredictable as life itself?
Authentic Dialogue: How ‘Blue Valentine’ Speaks the Language of Love and Loss
Dialogue in romantic dramas is often scripted to epitomize what we wish we’d say during those pivotal life-changing moments. Remember that heart-stopping line from “Jerry Maguire”? “You complete me.” Ah, a zinger that has permeated popular culture. But let’s face it, how often do real conversations fall so neatly into preordained boxes of wit and wisdom? Enter ‘Blue Valentine,’ where dialogue serves as an intricate dance of love, anguish, and a whole lot of awkward silence in between. It’s where the “You complete me” sentiment gets replaced with unscripted mumbles, stutters, and the occasional expletive.
The authenticity in dialogue within ‘Blue Valentine’ doesn’t just happen by chance. It’s a deliberate narrative choice that contributes to the film’s hyper-realistic atmosphere. Here’s where screenwriting tips can be mined for anyone aspiring to bring a more grounded, honest voice to their stories. It all starts with breaking away from the idea that dialogue needs to serve plot or be expository. In ‘Blue Valentine,’ characters often talk without necessarily moving the plot forward. They argue about unimportant things, interrupt each other, and let conversations hang — capturing the minutiae of real-life exchanges. This isn’t Aaron Sorkin’s ‘The West Wing’ where every sentence is a crafted piece of rhetoric. This is raw, messy, and chaotic conversation.
One of the writing tips I’d like to emphasize here is “listening.” Yes, it’s that simple and that complicated. Writers should listen to the world around them. Pick up on the rhythms, the idiosyncrasies, the way people really speak. Derek Cianfrance didn’t just want to tell a story; he wanted to present a slice of life. To achieve this, the director even went so far as to have Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams live together briefly to absorb each other’s habits and ways of speaking. It’s this kind of intense character study that transforms lines on a page into living, breathing entities.
You might argue that natural dialogue can result in mundane or trivial conversations, but that’s where the beauty lies. In ‘Blue Valentine,’ the dialogue often becomes poetic precisely because it’s so grounded. Just like in the real world, it’s not the overtly poetic lines that are remembered, but the simple, honest expressions. And this is where writing a screenplay diverges from simply writing—it’s the crafting of language to reflect authentic emotional landscapes.
Let’s not forget about subtext. Ah, subtext—the underlying, often unspoken thoughts and motives of your characters. In ‘Blue Valentine,’ what is left unsaid often speaks louder than the actual dialogue. Every pause, every stutter, and every silence is filled with unspoken emotions and hidden agendas. Think about the scene where Cindy confronts Dean about their deteriorating marriage. The pauses between their words are landmines of resentment and unspoken sorrow, and they’re just as vital to the narrative as any dialogue.
Subtext, my friends, should be a key element in your screenplay structure. It lends depth and dimension, making your characters more human, and their conflicts more relatable. If you’re interested in learning more, I recommend reading Robert McKee’s classic “Story” for a deep dive into the mechanics of subtext.
But if ‘Blue Valentine’ has any overarching lesson for aspiring writers, it’s this: let your characters speak, truly speak, in all their flawed, nonsensical, chaotic glory. Let them mumble if they must, let them pause to think, let them interrupt each other, and for heaven’s sake, let them be silent when words fail them. This is dialogue at its most unfiltered, and it’s from this honesty that truly memorable lines are born.
Also, if you’re out of ideas and looking for writing prompts to kickstart your creativity, try this: write a dialogue between two characters who are in love but are not allowed to say the word ‘love’ during their conversation. See what other expressions, behaviors, and words they use to convey their feelings. It’s an exercise that challenges you to think outside of conventional romantic dialogue and one that could very well produce your next great scene.
The Takeaway for Aspiring Writers: Drawing Lessons from the Narrative Ingenuity of ‘Blue Valentine’
When it comes to providing the kind of unvarnished, emotionally unguarded storytelling we see in ‘Blue Valentine,’ there’s a world of insight available to aspiring screenwriters and novelists alike. This isn’t just about packing your script with raw dialogue or mimicking the film’s intricate, nonlinear screenplay structure. It’s about the underlying craftsmanship, the nuanced character-building, and the profound respect for human complexity that make this movie a treasure trove of screenwriting tips for those daring enough to venture into the genre of romantic realism.
Let’s start by discussing an essential point—know your characters intimately. In the case of ‘Blue Valentine,’ director Derek Cianfrance had Michelle Williams and Ryan Gosling essentially ‘live’ their roles for several weeks. While not every writer has the luxury of such in-depth character study, you can approximate this immersion through detailed character profiles, asking what would this character do in a given situation rather than what does the story need them to do? Books like “Creating Character Arcs” by K.M. Weiland offer you a structured way to get into the bones of your characters.
Now, let’s talk about the complex structure of ‘Blue Valentine.’ Time, in this movie, isn’t just a linear progression of events. Instead, it serves as a lens through which we view the dissolution and genesis of Dean and Cindy’s relationship. If you’re considering a nonlinear storyline, be sure your reasoning goes beyond stylistic choice—it should deepen the audience’s understanding of the characters or theme. For more on this, you might want to look into “Anatomy of Story” by John Truby, which provides great insights into unconventional story structures.
You might find some writing prompts to be helpful as you explore the nonlinear aspects of storytelling. One exercise could be to take a pivotal moment in your script or novel and write it from the viewpoints of different timelines or alternative outcomes. For instance, how would a first meeting look five years down the road when seen through the lens of love, indifference, or even enmity?
Moving on, we come to the “uncomfortable scenes,” a hallmark of ‘Blue Valentine.’ The scenes that are difficult to watch are often the most telling. As writers, we might feel an impulse to protect our characters, to shield them from heartbreak or failure. But allowing your characters to endure hardship can often lead to the most poignant and true-to-life scenarios. It’s through adversity that characters reveal their true selves, and it’s often in these uncomfortable moments where the most memorable storytelling resides.
While we’re on this, here’s a quick writing tip: write the scenes that scare you. Yep, I mean those gut-wrenching, raw scenes you’re dreading to put on paper because they expose a level of vulnerability that makes even you, the writer, uncomfortable. Think about the searing doctor’s office scene in ‘Blue Valentine,’ where Michelle Williams’ character has to make a shattering decision. Your version of such a scene doesn’t have to be intense in the same way, but it should push you out of your comfort zone.
What makes ‘Blue Valentine’ stand apart in the world of romantic drama is its unflinching commitment to realism, which is not limited to dialogue or structure, but also permeates its thematic core. It doesn’t sugarcoat or idealize love; it shows it in all its beautiful, painful complexity. This is an invaluable lesson for anyone writing a screenplay or novel centered around romance or relationships: aim for honesty over fantasy, and your story will resonate on a much deeper level.
Finally, be patient with your craft. Authenticity, especially in writing tips that concern dialogue and character, often comes from revision, rewrites, and even starting from scratch. Don’t be discouraged if the first draft feels more like a soap opera than an authentic depiction of a relationship. Writing is a process.
So there you have it. ‘Blue Valentine’ isn’t just a film; it’s a masterclass in storytelling. Its attention to detail, its complex characters, its unique structure, and most importantly, its commitment to portraying love in its most unvarnished form offer lessons that go beyond mere tips. It challenges us to be braver, more honest, and more compassionate storytellers. And isn’t that what great writing is all about?
✍️ Whether you’re mastering the art of dialogue, structure, or character development, the power of AI can be a game-changer in your writing journey. My Free Ebook, ‘AI for Authors’ delves into how AI-powered prompts can provide a unique edge to your storytelling process. If you’re intrigued by the prospect of supercharging your fiction skills, download your free copy today and explore new horizons in creative writing.
A.I. in Screen Trade 