Introduction and Unraveling the Unconventional Screenplay Structure
“The Good Place,” an American television series by Michael Schur, premiered in 2016, quickly garnering attention for its distinctive blend of humor and moral philosophy. This attention was well-merited; the show beautifully and humorously navigates through thought-provoking ethical and philosophical quandaries, bringing new life to the world of comedy. But a significant part of its success can be attributed to the unique screenplay structure it utilized.
Unlike traditional sitcoms that adhere strictly to the three-act structure, “The Good Place” dares to break the mold. It not only expands the narrative into four acts but also intricately designs each season as a continual narrative, allowing character development and plot progression to span across multiple episodes and seasons, an approach that dramatically deviates from the episodic format common in sitcoms.
Typically, most sitcoms, especially those on network television, adopt an episodic structure where the storyline resolves by the end of each episode. This ‘reset’ mechanism allows viewers to drop in and out of a season without missing significant plot developments. It’s a time-proven structure that plays to the strengths of comfort and predictability. However, when writing a screenplay for a television show like “The Good Place,” these conventional rules are left at the door.
Instead of relying on episodic plotlines, “The Good Place” takes a serialized approach to storytelling. Each episode serves as a chapter in an ongoing narrative, building on the previous one and setting the stage for the next. The effect is an ever-evolving story that’s more akin to a long-form novel or film. The payoff for the audience? They become deeply invested in the characters’ arcs and the overall narrative, making the viewing experience more engaging and rewarding.
Season One, for example, centers on the protagonist Eleanor Shellstrop (played by Kristen Bell) who finds herself in the ‘Good Place’ by mistake and must learn to become ‘good’ to avoid being found out and sent to the ‘Bad Place.’ The season-long narrative culminates in a jaw-dropping twist in the final episode, completely upending the viewers’ understanding of the show and Eleanor’s character. This type of long-game storytelling is a clear deviation from the traditional sitcom structure and is a testament to the brilliance of the show’s innovative writing.
Moreover, the four-act structure employed within each episode of “The Good Place” provides ample room for plot and character development. Unlike the three-act structure, where the story develops through the ‘setup – confrontation – resolution’ progression, the addition of the fourth act introduces another layer of complication or development before moving towards the resolution. This structure lends a dynamic rhythm to the narrative, with each act ending on a suspenseful note that hooks the viewer for the next.
A memorable example can be found in the episode ‘Dance Dance Resolution’ (Season 2, Episode 2). Here, Michael (Ted Danson), the architect of the ‘Good Place,’ restarts the experiment several hundred times, each depicted within the first act. The subsequent acts delve into the aftermath of these restarts and the crew’s realization and resistance, with each act ending in an unexpected revelation or cliffhanger, effectively employing the four-act structure to keep viewers at the edge of their seats.
Moreover, the show’s bold narrative structure pushes the boundaries of what sitcoms can achieve, elevating it beyond mere humor and into the realm of philosophical exploration. The creators masterfully balance comedy and philosophy without compromising on either, offering viewers not just a good laugh but also food for thought.
The Art of Writing Humor: Crafting Jokes with Depth and Relevance
“The Good Place” has set itself apart in the pantheon of sitcoms through its distinctive brand of humor. Instead of relying on slapstick or farcical elements, the series brings depth and relevance to comedy, ingeniously weaving it with intellectual, ethical, and philosophical conversations. The humor is sharp, clever, and layered, taking viewers on a laughter-filled yet thought-provoking journey. But how exactly does “The Good Place” accomplish this feat?
First, it’s worth noting that the show’s humor largely stems from the script’s originality and cleverness. The screenwriting and dialogue are packed with puns, wordplay, and unexpected pop-culture references, often serving as the delivery mechanism for complex philosophical concepts.
One such example is the character of Chidi Anagonye, a moral philosophy professor. He often finds himself thrust into explaining dense philosophical concepts to the other characters. The show takes these opportunities to interlace humor with these heavy themes. Chidi’s anxiety, indecisiveness, and his “stomachaches,” for example, are the show’s humorous take on the burden of existential dread and moral absolutism. The series’ deft handling of humor and philosophy makes the ethical dilemmas central to the plot feel more palatable and engaging to a wide range of viewers.
One thing is clear: writing comedy is not simply about crafting one-liners or witty repartees. It is a precise and creative endeavor requiring a deep understanding of timing, character, and context. This is an essential screenwriting tip to keep in mind. “The Good Place” demonstrates this brilliantly, consistently delivering jokes that are relevant to the story and characters, and often even serve to further the narrative.
Let’s consider the character of Eleanor Shellstrop. Eleanor’s self-serving nature and carefree morality (or lack thereof) is a recurring source of humor. However, it also serves as a basis for her character growth and for introducing the concept of ethical improvement to the audience. When Eleanor hilariously misquotes philosophical teachings, her misunderstandings are more than just comedic moments; they drive home the point about her unfamiliarity with moral philosophy, building a foundation for her eventual transformation.
Additionally, “The Good Place” uses humor to keep the audience engaged during the show’s more philosophical moments. The writers strike a delicate balance between humor and philosophy, ensuring that the narrative doesn’t become too heavy-handed or didactic. As a result, even when exploring deep existential questions, the show retains its light-hearted tone and remains entertaining.
These techniques can serve as valuable writing prompts for those looking to infuse humor into their screenplays. Consider how humor can be used to explore a character’s flaws or to shed light on complex themes in an engaging and accessible manner. Also, contemplate how comedy can be used not just for laughs but as an effective tool to drive the narrative forward.
Moreover, the humor in “The Good Place” does not shy away from being absurd and offbeat, often venturing into the realm of the surreal. The show creates a surreal universe where frozen yogurt shops abound, giant shrimp fly through the sky, and the afterlife’s bureaucracy is as comically flawed as any earthly institution. This adds a whimsical flavor to the show’s humor, making the fantastical elements of the series both amusing and engaging.
While “The Good Place” draws heavily on philosophical concepts, the show remains hilariously human at its core. From Janet’s (a programmed guide in the Good Place) hilarious lack of human understanding to Eleanor’s casual irreverence, the series is filled with relatable humor that reminds us of our own quirks and foibles. These human-centric jokes offer a grounded contrast to the show’s more high-concept humor, resulting in a nuanced comedic palette that keeps the audience engaged and entertained.
Intertwining Philosophy with Comedy: Masterful Character Development and Plot Progression
“The Good Place” is renowned for its ingenious blend of comedy and philosophy, a unique formula that has not only entertained audiences but also sparked meaningful conversations about morality, ethics, and what it means to be a good person. But beyond the intellectual musings and belly laughs, what truly stands out is how seamlessly the show intertwines these elements to drive character development and plot progression.
The genius of the show lies in the fact that the philosophical underpinnings are not just side notes or intellectual exercises, but the very engine that drives the narrative and shapes the characters. From moral philosophy professor Chidi’s ethical dilemmas to Eleanor’s journey from selfishness to selflessness, philosophical ideas are deftly woven into the characters’ arcs and the unfolding plot, lending depth and complexity to the narrative.
The clever use of philosophy in “The Good Place” is not a simple matter of scripting intellectual dialogues or presenting philosophical dilemmas. It involves integrating these elements into the DNA of the story, allowing them to influence character growth and plot progression. This task requires a nuanced understanding of character development and narrative structure, a skill that is critical when writing a screenplay.
The character of Eleanor Shellstrop is a prime example of this masterful blend of philosophy and character development. Eleanor begins as a selfish, impulsive individual who has landed in the Good Place by mistake. As she embarks on her journey to become a ‘better person’ and secure her place in the Good Place, she grapples with complex ethical and philosophical concepts.
Eleanor’s evolution is not a straightforward journey. It’s filled with relapses and epiphanies, struggles and victories, making her character arc believable and compelling. Her growth is not driven by external events alone, but by her internal moral wrestling and philosophical enlightenment. By aligning character development with philosophical exploration, the writers have created an engaging and thought-provoking narrative.
Similarly, the philosophy-comedy blend also shapes the show’s plot progression. The storyline of “The Good Place” isn’t just about the characters trying to navigate the afterlife; it’s about them grappling with profound questions like “What does it mean to be good?” and “Can people change?” These questions form the backbone of the narrative, guiding the characters’ actions and decisions, and influencing the overall direction of the plot.
Consider the show’s innovative approach to its primary conflict. Rather than opting for traditional sitcom conflicts such as love triangles or career dilemmas, “The Good Place” presents its characters with moral and philosophical predicaments. This approach not only differentiates the show from traditional sitcoms but also provides a fresh and intriguing narrative that keeps the audience engaged and invested.
To successfully integrate complex ideas into a screenplay, it’s crucial to ensure these elements serve the story rather than overshadow it. While “The Good Place” delves into dense philosophical concepts, it never loses sight of its narrative or characters. The philosophical elements are weaved into the story organically, enhancing the plot and characters rather than detracting from them.
One practical writing tip to achieve this balance is to ensure that the philosophical or complex ideas are intrinsically linked to the characters’ goals, conflicts, and motivations. This way, these elements don’t feel tacked on or incongruous but become integral to the story.
In conclusion, “The Good Place” stands as a shining example of the seamless intertwining of philosophy with comedy. It demonstrates how complex ideas, when handled skillfully, can drive character development and plot progression, leading to an engaging and layered narrative. The show’s ability to explore profound philosophical concepts while maintaining its comedic essence is a testament to the creative prowess of its writers.
For those venturing into the realm of screenwriting, “The Good Place” offers valuable insights. It showcases the potential of blending comedy with thought-provoking themes and exemplifies how to use philosophy to shape characters and plot. By studying its brilliance, aspiring writers can gain a better understanding of how to weave complex ideas into their narratives effectively.
“The Good Place” thus serves as a reminder that sitcoms – and indeed, any genre – can be a platform for intellectual exploration and profound storytelling. It underscores the importance of daring to push creative boundaries, to defy conventions, and to explore new narrative possibilities. And above all, it shows us that humor and philosophy, laughter and thought, can indeed make a good place in the world of storytelling.
✍️ Whether you’re mastering the art of dialogue, structure, or character development, the power of AI can be a game-changer in your writing journey. My Free Ebook, ‘AI for Authors’ delves into how AI-powered prompts can provide a unique edge to your storytelling process. If you’re intrigued by the prospect of supercharging your fiction skills, download your free copy today and explore new horizons in creative writing.
A.I. in Screen Trade 